subject-questions with 'Who?' Who's ready? | subject-answer + auxiliary I am/John is etc. | be |
Who's got my keys? | I have /John has etc. | have |
Who makes the decisions? | I do/John does etc. | do/does |
Who paid the waiter? | I did /John did etc | did |
Who can explain this? | I can/John can etc. | modals |
subject-questions with 'What?', 'Which?' and 'Whose?'
What made you jump? The cat did
Which one suits me best? The red one does
Whose telephone rang7 Mine did
13 Questions, answers, negatives
Notes on the form of subject-questions
1 A subject-question normally asks for the identity of the subject.
There is no inversion and the question has the same word order as
the statement [compare > 13.31ns1,2]:
Subject verb object subject-answer
statement: Someone paid the waiter
subject-question. Who paid the waiter? John did
Compare a Who question which asks for the object of a statement:
Subject verb object object-answer
statement John paid the waiter
Yes/No question Did John pay the waiter?
Who(m)>question. Who(m) did John pay'' The waiter
2 Answers to subject-questions often echo the auxiliary used in the
question, either in the affirmative or the negative:
Who can play the piano? ~ I can /I can't
When the subject question-word is followed by a verb in the simple present or past, then do, does or did may be used in the answer: Who wants a lift? / do Who won? - We did When the answer is a name or a noun, we often omit the auxiliary: Who was at the door? - The postman (was) Informally, me is often used in place of / in the answer [> 4.7.2]: Who wants some more tea? - Me (in place of / do)
3 What, Which and Whose can combine with other subject-words: What number is? Which boy likes? Whose car is?
|
|
4 Subject question-words can be followed by singular or plural verbs. In everyday speech we commonly use a singular verb after, e.g. Who? even when we are asking for a plural answer:
Who is coming tonight? John is /John and Sally are
However, plural verbs can occur quite naturally after subject
questions with Who, Which and What:
Who are playing in the orchestra?
Who have won Nobel Prizes for literature in the past ten years?