is usually preferred to / haven't always got to be
Lack of necessity, etc.: present/future
11.56.1 Lack of necessity: 'needn't', 'don't have to', 'haven't got to'
Reference to present or future time can be made as follows These forms are normally interchangeable [compare > 11.57.1]
Lack of necessity madvisability prohibition
be at the office (until 9 tomorrow)
I needn't leave until 9 (tomorrow)
don't have to be leaving untill 9 (tomorrow)
(Haven't got to is not generally used with progressive forms)
Won t (and shan t in BrE [> 9.36n3]) will combine with have to and
need to (full verb) for explicit reference to the future
/ won't need to/have to be at the office before 9 tomorrow
Inadvisability/prohibition: 'shouldn't/oughtn't to/mustn't', etc.
You shouldn't/oughtn't to/can't/mustn't be late for meetings
('present/habitual')
You shouldn't/oughtn't to/had better not/can't/mustn't be late
tomorrow (future)
Shouldn t oughtn t to had better not can t and mustn't are used to refer to the future, although they do not have future forms Possible alternatives are Shouldn t/oughtn t to/had better not can be replaced by
It won't be advisable (for her) to play games for the next month Can t and mustn t can be replaced by
We won't be allowed to park here for long
You will be forbidden to enter the courtroom before 9 30
Traffic in this street will be prohibited by law
Lack of necessity/inadvisability/prohibition: perfect/past
11.57.1 Lack of necessity: 'needn't have', 'didn't have to', 'didn't
need to'
Thes e forms mean roughly the same thing in e g / needn't have gone to the office yesterday I didn't have to (or/ didn't need to)go to the office yesterday (have and need are stressed) (= I went there, but it was unnecessary)
|
|
When have and need are unstressed, they mean something different from needn't have
I didn't have toll didn't need to go to the office yesterday
(= I knew it was unnecessary and I didn't go)
Because modals are defective [> 11.4 11.6.1] appropriate alternatives must be used in some tenses
It wouldn't have been necessary to change at Leeds if we had
caught the earlier train
I haven't had to cancel my appointment after all
If he had asked me I would have had to tell him the truth
11.57.2 Inadvisability: 'shouldn't have' and 'oughtn't to have'
Both these forms suggest criticism of an action
You shouldn't have paid the plumber in advance
Oughtn't to have
or failure to observe a prohibition
You shouldn't have stopped on the motorway
Oughtn't to have
11 Modal auxiliaries and related verbs
Uses of modals to express habit